Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with HBO (Naughty Dog / PlayStation Productions) or the show's producers · how we work

Fan theoryUpdated Nov 18, 2026 · 10 sources

Community Debate: Judging Abby, Ellie's Choices, and the Salt Lake Crew

Recent fan discussions on Reddit examine the complex choices and character dynamics of The Last of Us Part II. From evaluating Abby's perspective and the Salt Lake City crew to questioning Ellie's honesty and tactical decisions, the community remains divided on how to judge the central cast.

Divided Reactions to Abby and the Golf Scene

Fan discussions on r/thelastofus continue to weigh Abby's role and narrative execution. One Reddit user noted that while Abby's section initially felt slow and exhausting, discovering her personal story ultimately made the experience memorable, even as other posts speculate on the reasons behind her anger.

Other community members remain critical or examine the darker side of her actions. One post reflected on how Abby brutally put down a troubled man who had harmed innocent people in a lawless world, stating they would never forgive her. Another user criticized the HBO version of the golf scene, arguing that if Abby was given a monologue, the scene should have included a back-and-forth exchange between her and Joel like the game.

Ellie's Secrets and the Aquarium Encounter

Ellie's internal conflicts and tactical choices on Day 3 are also driving fan theories and debate. One fan pointed to a journal entry on the road to the aquarium where Ellie decides she cannot tell Dina and Jesse what Joel did because they would not understand, and wonders if she even understands it herself. The poster contrasted this secrecy with Part 1, where Ellie was mostly honest outside of basic survival bluffs with enemies like David or hiding a comic swiped from Bill's stash.

Another Reddit user analyzed the timeline at the aquarium, noting that Tommy and Jesse arrived right after Ellie killed Owen and Mel. The fan argued that if Ellie had originally gone with Jesse, the three of them could have confronted Owen and Mel together, preventing what Ellie had to do and stopping her from dropping her map.

The Salt Lake Crew, Dina, and Broader Themes

Supporting characters are also receiving fresh scrutiny on r/thelastofus. One fan asked for community thoughts on the relationship dynamics and deaths of Abby's Salt Lake City friend group, expressing a wish to see more story for Manny, Nora, Mel, and smaller characters like Jordan. Meanwhile, another fan questioned a recent surplus of online hate directed at Dina, calling her a favorite character.

At a broader level, fans are debating why some players dislike that Ellie spared Abby, noting that critics often point to a cliché revenge message. Still, supporters praise how Part II handles themes of factionalism and 'us versus them,' stating that the ongoing back-and-forth debates make them appreciate both Part 1 and Part II even more.

Two sides of the debate

Appreciating the Narrative Choices

  • Getting to know Abby's personal story makes the narrative a lasting experience, even if her section initially feels slow and exhausting.
  • The execution of 'us versus them' and factionalism fuels deep back-and-forth debates that make fans love both Part 1 and Part II more.
  • Ellie's journal entries add depth by contrasting her Part 1 honesty with her burden of hiding what Joel did from Dina and Jesse.

Critiquing Character Actions and Execution

  • Some players dislike that Ellie did not kill Abby, viewing the ending as a cliché 'revenge is bad' message.
  • The HBO golf scene gave Abby a monologue without giving Joel and Abby a proper back-and-forth exchange.
  • Ellie refusing to go with Jesse led directly to her killing Owen and Mel alone and dropping her map just before Tommy and Jesse arrived.
  • The Salt Lake City friend group—including Manny, Nora, Mel, and Jordan—left some fans wanting more story about their dynamics.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: Which Part II character topic do you find most compelling to debate?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think the story would have benefited from spending more time with the Salt Lake City crew, or did their screen time feel right?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from The Last of Us S3